What happened today in history?
What happened
today in history?
Sep 23
Back

The Bonehead Play of 1908: Merkle's Missed Opportunity

The Infamous Incident of 1908

The 1908 baseball season is notorious for one unforgettable moment known as the "Bonehead Play" involving Fred Merkle. It took place on September 23 during a game between the New York Giants and the Chicago Cubs at the Polo Grounds in New York City. This moment would not only affect a pivotal game but also have lasting consequences on the pennant race and Major League Baseball's history.

Fred Merkle's Mistake

With the game tied at 1-1 and two outs in the bottom of the ninth inning, Merkle, who was on first base, came around to score what he thought was a game-winning hit by Al Bridwell. However, in his excitement, he failed to touch second base before running off the field to celebrate. Cubs infielder Johnny Evers, realizing the oversight, got hold of the ball and stepped on second base, recording the third out. This ruling meant that the run did not count, and the game ended in a tie.

The Aftermath of the Game

As a result of this incident, the officials decided to replay the game. When the Cubs and Giants faced off again, the Cubs emerged victorious. This loss cost the Giants the National League pennant, and the Cubs went on to the World Series, ultimately securing their place in baseball history.

Legacy of the Merkle Incident

Fred Merkle's failure to touch second base is remembered not just for the immediate consequences it had on the season but also for how it has since been immortalized in baseball lore. The term "Merkle's Boner" continues to be used in discussions about players failing to execute fundamental plays.

Baseball Consequences

After the Merkle incident, Major League Baseball instituted stricter rules to ensure players must touch all bases in order before claiming runs. This incident helped highlight the importance of base running discipline in the sport.

Impact on Fred Merkle

Though Merkle would continue his career in baseball, the "Bonehead Play" would forever overshadow his legacy. He faced criticism and became symbolic of how one mistake can impact a player's career and a team's fortune.

Fun Fact

Merkle’s Interesting Fact

Interestingly, despite the infamous nature of the play, Fred Merkle had a solid career, and years later, he was a minor leaguer and managed teams after his playing days were over.

Additional Resources

Recommended Reading on Fred Merkle

For those wishing to explore further, check out "The Baseball Hall of Shame", which recounts legendary blunders including this one, and "The Giants of 1908" for a deep dive into that historic season.