Secretary of State Mike Pompeo's Decision
Changing Perspectives on West Bank Settlements
On November 18, 2019, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo made a significant announcement that altered the United States' longstanding approach to Israel's West Bank settlements. After 24 years of official policy labeling these settlements as illegal under international law, Pompeo declared that the US no longer views them as inherently illegal. This change created waves in international relations and shifted the dynamic of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Legal Implications of the New Policy
By reversing the former stance, Pompeo aligned with the view that the legality of the settlements should be determined by negotiations between Israel and Palestine rather than international law. This marked a substantial shift, suggesting a permissive approach towards Israel’s ongoing settlement expansions, which critics argue undermines the prospects for peace and violates the rights of Palestinians.
The Reactions to Pompeo's Announcement
International Backlash
Pompeo's decision faced immediate backlash from numerous countries and organizations worldwide. Many critics, including the European Union and United Nations, reaffirmed their stance that the settlements contravene international law and called for the US to reconsider its alliance with Israel regarding this issue. The announcement raised alarms about the future of a potential two-state solution, which relies heavily on the status of these settlements.
Support from Pro-Israel Groups
Conversely, pro-Israel groups celebrated this reversal as a victory. They argued that recognizing the legitimacy of the settlements strengthens Israel's strategic and historical claims to the land. Advocates expected this shift would boost Israeli confidence in its territorial policies, reinforcing claims over areas viewed as integral by Israeli citizens.
Fun Fact
Historical Context of the Settlements
The development of Israeli settlements in the West Bank began after the Six-Day War in 1967. This military engagement resulted in Israeli control over the West Bank, and since then, various governments have offered differing views on the legality and expansion of these communities.
Additional Resources
Recommended Reading on US-Israel Relations
For those interested in deeper exploration of this topic, consider reading “The Iron Wall: Israel and the Arab World” by Avi Shlaim or “We Were the Lucky Ones” by Georgia Hunter, which provide diverse perspectives on the historical and ongoing challenges of Israeli policies and settlements.
Continue with Google